How much are each of us unconsciously conditioned by the culture we live in, and how profoundly does it affect us? Sometimes our thoughts, beliefs, values, and behaviors stemming from our individual cultures are so pervasive and embedded that we can't perceive them the old adage about describing water to a fish. 

Researchers who go into other cultures to study them often go in with their own lens to try and find data...and of course, the data they find is typical of the researchers own culture because it has to go through their own cultural filters. 

Patricia M. Coleman, Harvard-trained Professor of Psychology sums up a fascinating study:

“Cole, Gay, Glick, and Sharp (1971) took an object-sorting task to Liberia, where they presented it to their Kpelle participants. There were 20 objects that divided evenly into the linguistic categories of food, implements, food containers, and clothing.

Instead of doing the taxonomic sorts expected by the researchers, participants persistently made functional pairings (Glick, 1968). For example, rather than sorting objects into groups of tools and foods, participants would put a potato and a knife together because “you take the knife and cut the potato” (Cole et al., 1971, pg. 79).

According to Glick, participants often justified their pairings by stating “that a wise man could only do such and such” (Glick, 1968, p. 13). In total exasperation, the researchers “finally said, ‘How would a fool do it?’ The result was a set of nice linguistically ordered categories—four of them with five items each” (Glick, 1968, p. 13).

In short, the researchers’ criterion for intelligent behavior was the participants’ criterion for foolish; the participants’ criterion for wise behavior was the researchers’ criterion for stupid.”

—Greenfield, P. M. (1997). You can’t take it with you: Why ability assessments don’t cross cultures. American Psychologist, 52(10), 1115-1124.

These kind of mistaken assumptions was also a significant factor in the way First Peoples were so harshly treated by their respective colonizers throughout history. Colonizers brought their own expectations and lenses and thrust their belief systems on those they were colonizing. Forcing indigenous individuals to dress in the European way, insisting their children go to school, and converting them to Christianity are just a few of the ways that dominant cultures have acted out their unconscious, insensitive beliefs at to the detriment of others throughout history.

While some on the side of colonization no doubt believed they were doing the (only) right thing, and perhaps had good intentions, a depth perspective insists we must always try to bracket our beliefs (that is, consciously acknowledge them as our own and set them aside) and they try to put ourselves in the other's shoes.

There's just no way we can begin to understand a culture we did not grow up in, unless we, too are embedded in it for a very long time. I remember a professor telling me in a culture class when I was an undergrad that it's really difficult for a person who learns a second language to properly adopt and use expletives because someone who is foreign to the culture and language will always lack the innate nuance that is required to properly swear! I thought this was funny at the time, but it always stuck with me and I have paid attention to it over the years when I met people who did it. Sure enough, at times, it can seem incongruent, inappropriate, harsh, or out of place when it occurs.

While we may not be able to change our own cultural conditioning, awareness goes a long way to being open to the fact that when something bothers us about someone from another culture, it's not the whole story. We might first turn the lens of inquiry on ourselves to be open to the fact that we are different from each other, even if it's not always obvious why. When we can start to be more tolerant of differing belief systems, even if we don't agree with them, we begin to feed the world soul and enable our inherent connectivity as human beings to emerge.

Views: 3872


You need to be a member of Depth Psychology Alliance to add comments!

Join Depth Psychology Alliance

Comment by Steve Staniek on February 22, 2019 at 5:55am

Yes, it is difficult, but if we are to liberate ourselves from the powerful deceptions created by our own  cultural conditioning, then we need to transcend that deep conditioning that has become part of our identity. Cultural conditioning often works against us in powerful ways as we struggle to grow our ethical minds, and raise them above the cultural thinking that traps us in thought forms prescribed by our culture. "We all think this way, so it must be okay because consensus thinking creates the reality that we all support."  ...We are trapped in thought forms that are not our own, but imposed on us by external sources, that do not necessarily have our best interests at heart. Those cultural dos and dont's, shape us for better or worse.

We must learn to throw off the social, religious,and political conditioning that has shaped us, and made us slaves to the culture we were born into, in order to grow beyond their constraints.   

Comment by J.D.Stephen Flynn on May 18, 2015 at 1:35am
Like it Alex,
To speak from the comfort of ones own home.. My soft settee, the grand breakfast within, I am indeed blessed.
Not sure what lies ahead though. Pain has no respect of person or position. Suffering has little regard for any, and death follows no rule. What is one mans suffering is but a mere neusence to another.
For me, I am indeed blessed, as I experience the content of all religion, an inner delight, thankfulness and contentment, albeit each hold its opposition within.
We humans are far more dangerous than the whole animal kingdom altogether.
Technology too has its own opposit offering dilemma to its mulipal users.
Comment by J.D.Stephen Flynn on May 16, 2015 at 4:56pm
Hi Bonnie,
Jung would have it that we use what we are to study what we are, so science is thus flawed.
Technology offers huge development, but then again everything has its opposite. It also provides the power of huge destruction. Maybe our intelligence relating to Thinking is outstripping our ability to cope with it.
Prejudice is Universal so too our observations of other culture, even our own norm now will be viewed with distain or whatever in the next generation.
Eg,.as a boy, homosexuality (for males only) was considered a crime, it didn't exist (officially) among women.
Infanticide was inditable too.
Any person could set up a GP practice and suicide was self murder, as such an attempt was also an inditable offence.
Only lately there has been radical change. So who is to observe whom? Such observations become ludicrous.
History is thus bias and omits the unacceptable, say nothing of what is conscious or unconscious in the hand that controls the pen, or the senses of modern day tech.
Belief is cerceptable to propergander and as Jung would have it, all belief is second hand.
So where do we go, and for what?
Education is fodder for industry rather than personal development.
No! Technology is but the expression of out behaviour and thus controlled within our contemporary prejudice.
The prospect of it offering other, such as some kind of spiritual breakthrough is, once again looking to the outer world for inner development, when the outer world is a mere reflection of the inner reality.
So we continue in the same vein as before.
Sad lot are we not?

A hub for "all things Depth Psychology," with over 5000 members, Depth Psychology Alliance is FREE to join. Simply sign UP or sign IN to comment or post.

Click the logos for more information!——————————————————————





Subscribe to the "Latest Activity" RSS 

feed for Depth Psychology Alliance


© 2020   Created by James Newell.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service